Anne Dudley Bradstreet(1612–1672) had received an excellent education in theology, history, and literature. In her free time, she wrote poetry. The “Dialogue Between Old England and New” was among the most prominently partisan of her works highlighting the religious and political history of England as keyed towards the Puritan cause, rather than that of the Crown.

Alas, dear mother, fairest queen and best,
With honor, wealth, and peace happy and blessed,
What ails you hang your head, and cross your arms,
And sit in the dust to sigh these sad alarms?
What deluge of new woes thus overwhelm
The glories of your ever-famous realm?
What means this wailing tone, this mournful guise?
Ah, tell your daughter; she may sympathize.

Old England.

Art ignorant indeed of these my woes,
Or must my forced tongue these griefs disclose,
And must myself dissect my tattered state,
Which amazed Christendom stands wondering at?
And you a child, a limb, and does not feel
My weakened fainting body now to reel?
This physic-purging potion I have taken
Will bring consumption or an ague[1] quaking,
Unless some cordial you fetch from high,
Which present help may ease my malady.
If I decease, do think you shall survive?
Or by my wasting state do think to thrive?
Then weigh our case, if it be not justly sad.
Let me lament alone, while you are glad.

New England.

And thus, alas, your state you much deplore
In general terms, but will not say wherefore.
What medicine shall I seek to cure this woe,
If the wound’s so dangerous, I may not know?
. . .
Your humble child entreats you show your grief.
Though arms nor purse she has for your relief—
Such is her poverty,—yet shall be found
A suppliant for your help, as she is bound.

Old England.

I must confess some of those sores you name
My beauteous body at this present maim,
But foreign foe nor feigned friend I fear,
For they have work enough, you know, elsewhere.
. . .
For wants, sure some I feel, but more I fear;
And for the pestilence, who knows how near?
Famine and plague, two sisters of the sword,
Destruction to a land does soon afford.
They’re for my punishments ordained on high,
Unless your tears prevent it speedily.
But yet I answer not what you demand
To show the grievance of my troubled land.
Before I tell the effect I’ll show the cause,
Which are my sins—the breach of sacred laws:
Idolatry, supplanter of a nation,
With foolish superstitious adoration,
Are liked and countenanced by men of might,
The gospel is trod down and has no right.
Church offices are sold and bought for gain
That pope had hope to find Rome here again.
For oaths and blasphemies did ever ear
From Beelzebub himself such language hear?
What scorning of the saints of the most high!
What injuries did daily on them lie!
What false reports, what nicknames did they take,
Not for their own, but for their Master’s sake!
And you, poor soul, were jeered among the rest;
Your flying for the truth I made a jest.
For Sabbath-breaking and for drunkenness
Did ever land profaneness more express?
From crying bloods yet cleansed am not I,
Martyrs and others dying causelessly.
How many princely heads on blocks lay down
. . .

New England.

To all you’ve said, sad mother, I assent.
Your fearful sins great cause there is to lament.
My guilty hands (in part) hold up with you,
A sharer in your punishment’s my due.
But all you say amounts to this effect,
Not what you feel, but what you do expect.
Pray, in plain terms, what is your present grief?
Then let’s join heads and hands for your relief.

Old England.

Well, to the matter, then. There’s grown of late
’Twixt king and peers a question of state:
Which is the chief, the law, or else the king?
One said, it’s he; the other, no such thing.
It is said my better part in Parliament
To ease my groaning land show their intent
To crush the proud, and right to each man deal,
To help the church, and stay the commonweal.
So many obstacles comes in their way
As puts me to a stand what I should say.
Old customs, new prerogatives stood on.
Had they not held law fast, all had been gone,
Which by their prudence stood them in such stead
They took high Strafford lower by the head,
And to their Laud[2] be it spoke they held in the tower
All England’s metropolitan that hour.
This done, an act they would have passed fain
No prelate should his bishopric retain.
Here tugged they hard indeed, for all men saw
This must be done by Gospel, not by law.
. . .
But now I come to speak of my disaster.
Contention’s grown ’twixt subjects and their master,
They worded it so long they fell to blows,
That thousands lay on heaps. Here bleed my woes.
I that no wars so many years have known
Am now destroyed and slaughtered by mine own.
But could the field alone this strife decide,
One battle, two, or three I might abide,
But these may be beginnings of more woe—
Who knows but this may be my overthrow!
Oh, pity me in this sad perturbation,
My plundered towns, my houses’ devastation,
My weeping virgins, and my young men slain,
My wealthy trading fallen, my dearth of grain.
The seed-time’s come, but ploughman has no hope
Because he knows not who shall inn[3] his crop.
The poor they want their pay, their children bread,
Their woeful mothers’ tears unpitied.
If any pity in thy heart remain,
Or any child-like love you do retain,
For my relief do what there lies in you,
And recompense that good I ‘ve done to you.

New England.

Dear mother, cease complaints, and wipe your eyes,
Shake off your dust, cheer up, and now arise.
You are my mother, nurse, I once your flesh,
Your sunken bowels gladly would refresh.
Your griefs I pity, but soon hope to see
Out of your troubles much good fruit to be;
To see these latter days of hoped-for good
Though now beclouded all with tears and blood.
After dark popery the day did clear;
But now the sun in his brightness shall appear.
Blessed be the nobles of thy noble land
With ventured lives for truth’s defense that stand.
Blessed be your Commons, who for common good
And your infringed laws have boldly stood.
Blessed be your counties, who did aid you still
With hearts and states to testify their will.
Blessed be your preachers, who do cheer you on.
Oh, cry the sword of God and Gideon!
And shall I not on them wish Meroz’ curse
That help you not with prayers, with alms, and purse?
And for myself, let miseries abound
If mindless of your state I ever be found.
These are the days the church’s foes to crush,
To root out popelings, head, tail, branch, and rush.
Let’s bring Baal’s vestments forth to make a fire,
Their mitres, surplices, and all their attire,
Copes, rochets, croziers, and such empty trash,
And let their names consume, but let the flash
Light Christendom, and all the world to see
We hate Rome’s whore, with all her trumpery.
. . .
Out of all mists such glorious days will bring
That dazzled eyes, beholding, much shall wonder
At that your settled peace, your wealth, and splendor,
Your church and weal established in such manner
That all shall joy that you displayed your banner,
. . .


[1] fever and chills Return

[2] Archbishop William Laud (1573–1645) resented attempts by Puritans and others to reform the Anglican establishment and used his office to advocate laws intended to persecute religious dissenters whenever possible. Return

[3] archaic; “put up” or harvest Return


The Poems of Mrs. Anne Bradstreet (1612–1672) Together with her Prose Remains, With an Introduction by Charles Eliot Norton (The Duodecimos, 1897).